I am neutral on this, I think at the end the user will decide what system she/he prefers, both might have its advantages.
However my point was and is that the process of installation and deinstallation of content (map,mod,tools, etc.) needs to be automated. That would be the next generation of content databases imo and something that the allready existing databases currently do not offer, to name a few:
http://www.mapraider.com/
http://medalofhonor.filefront.com/
http://www.mohfun-gamers.de/HP/index...te=files&cat=1
So for that purpose a webservice that runs alongside the database and serves external tools, webbrowsers or the game clients themself would be a nice thing.
The goal is that the user then will be able to just pick a webservice link from a list of available databases, and she/he can browse and search through the available content and install the selected stuff with a single click.
I will write and open-source that webservice interface based on asp.net / mysql and also the installation/deinstallation tool as a library so other tools can make use of it.